Inclusion of IBS and CBS in the ICMS and ISS Tax Bases Is Already Triggering Legal Disputes and May Affect Companies Starting in 2027.
| Several state and municipal tax authorities have adopted the position that IBS and CBS must be included in the ICMS and ISS tax bases starting in 2027. If this interpretation prevails, companies may face an indirect increase in their tax burden during the Tax Reform transition. Although there are already court decisions favorable to taxpayers, the issue has been gaining prominence in the courts and calls for a preventive assessment by potentially affected companies. |
The transition to the new consumption taxation system is already revealing one of the first significant controversies of the Tax Reform: the possibility that IBS and CBS will broaden the ICMS and ISS tax bases during the period in which the current model and the new system coexist.
Several state tax administrations have begun to express the view that the amounts corresponding to the Tax on Goods and Services (“IBS”) and the Contribution on Goods and Services (“CBS”) must be included in the ICMS tax base once those taxes start to be effectively levied. At the same time, the City of São Paulo has already released operational guidance for the NFS-e (electronic service invoice) that assumes IBS and CBS will be included in the ISS tax base starting in 2027.
On the other side, there are already court decisions favorable to taxpayers, not yet binding, ruling out the inclusion of IBS and CBS in the ISS and ICMS tax bases. In the case of São Paulo’s ICMS, however, on November 9, 2026, the Presidency of the São Paulo State Court of Justice granted a request for suspension of injunction and judgment filed by the State of São Paulo (Case No. 2270251-20.2026.8.26.0000), suspending the effects of ten of those decisions.
This scenario reveals a new front of tax controversy with potentially significant financial impact for companies across various sectors of the economy.
The Controversy Is Already Being Incorporated by Tax Authorities and Electronic Systems
Until recently, the discussion was largely confined to academic studies, tax rulings, and forward-looking analyses on the implementation of the Tax Reform.
In recent months, however, several states have begun to formalize the position that IBS and CBS must be included in the ICMS tax base once they become due. São Paulo, Paraná, Minas Gerais, Pernambuco, Alagoas, and the Federal District already have administrative statements to that effect.
At the municipal level, the discussion has become even more concrete following the release of new operational rules for São Paulo’s NFS-e for taxable events occurring from 2027 onward. The formulas published by the City assume that the amounts corresponding to IBS and CBS are included in the ISS tax base, which may result in higher taxation on the provision of services.
In other words, the controversy is already starting to be reflected in the billing systems and electronic tax documents that companies will use during the Tax Reform transition.
It is worth noting, however, that most of the administrative statements identified so far rule out including IBS and CBS in the ICMS tax base during 2026, a period in which the new taxes are experimental and are not actually collected. The controversy centers mainly on subsequent years, especially from 2027 onward, when IBS and CBS will begin to be effectively levied.
Potential increase in tax burden
If the interpretation currently adopted by some state and municipal tax authorities prevails, taxpayers will be subject to ICMS and ISS on amounts corresponding to IBS and CBS.
From an economic standpoint, the controversy involves the possibility that taxes created by the Tax Reform will broaden the tax base of taxes that will remain in force during the transition period.
Depending on the business model, revenue volume, and applicable rates, the financial impact may be significant and may directly affect:
- operating margins;
- pricing policy;
- cash flow;
- long-term contracts;
- accounting provisions;
- tax and financial planning.
- The effects tend to be more significant for companies in the services, technology, retail, manufacturing, logistics, infrastructure, agribusiness, and e-commerce sectors.
There Are Solid Legal Grounds to Challenge the Assessment
Although the tax authorities’ position has been gaining strength, the legal validity of this inclusion remains disputed.
The main arguments in favor of taxpayers include:
- the absence of an express legal provision requiring IBS and CBS to be included in the ICMS and ISS tax bases;;
- the understanding that the amounts corresponding to the new taxes do not constitute the taxpayer’s own revenue;
- a possible violation of the principles of legality, neutrality, and transparency that guided the Tax Reform;
- conceptual alignment with the reasoning adopted by the Federal Supreme Court (STF) in the ruling that excluded ICMS from the PIS and Cofins tax base.
- In addition to the administrative positions already released by various federative entities, the first court decisions on the matter are beginning to emerge.
With respect to ISS, the 9th Public Treasury Court of São Paulo granted an injunction (Case No. 1161497-36.2026.8.26.0053) ensuring the company’s right to pay ISS without including IBS and CBS in its tax base from January 1, 2027, for as long as the transition period provided for in Constitutional Amendment No. 132/2023 lasts. The decision also prevents the City from issuing tax assessments against the company, registering it in the active debt roll or in CADIN (the federal registry of delinquent public-sector debtors), and denying tax compliance certificates.
With respect to ICMS, there are decisions favorable to taxpayers, including the judgment of the 16th Public Treasury Court of São Paulo (Case No. 1138866-98.2026.8.26.0053), based on the premise that IBS and CBS are revenues of the taxing entities and not of the taxpayer, as well as the judgment issued by the 2nd Public Treasury Court of Santos (Writ of Mandamus No. 1005586-56.2026.8.26.0562), which ruled out the inclusion of these taxes in the state tax base with respect to the petitioning company. In Minas Gerais, there are also favorable injunctions, such as the one granted by the 1st Business, Public Treasury, and Public Registry Court of the District of Contagem (Case No. 1024630-18.2026.8.13.0079), which ordered the tax authority to refrain from requiring the company to pay ICMS in the manner set out in Taxpayer Ruling No. 020/2026.
This initially favorable scenario, however, suffered a significant setback before the São Paulo State Court of Justice.
President of the São Paulo Court of Justice Suspends Decisions Favorable to Taxpayers
On November 9, 2026, the Presidency of the Court, at the request of the State of São Paulo, suspended the effectiveness of judgments and injunctions issued in ten writs of mandamus, including the decisions of the 16th Public Treasury Court of São Paulo and the 2nd Public Treasury Court of Santos mentioned above (Suspension of Injunction and Judgment No. 2270251-20.2026.8.26.0000).
The decision was based on the risk of serious harm to the public economy, in light of the State Treasury Department’s estimate of a revenue loss of R$ 10.2 billion in 2027, and on the potential multiplier effect of the lawsuits, even allowing the measure to be extended to new decisions on the same subject matter, upon request by the State.
The suspension, however, does not examine the merits of the controversy, as the Presidency itself expressly noted, nor does it rule out the possibility that the issue may be decided in favor of taxpayers by the competent courts. In addition, its effects do not extend to the discussions concerning ISS or to those involving other States of the Federation.
The Right Time to Assess Preventive Measures
In tax matters, the higher courts have frequently modulated the effects of their decisions, limiting the recovery of amounts paid in the past to taxpayers who had already filed lawsuits, as occurred in the judgment of Topic 69 of the general repercussion regime (exclusion of ICMS from the PIS and Cofins tax base). In this context, an early analysis of preventive measures may be decisive for preserving rights and mitigating future financial impacts.
The decision of the Presidency of the São Paulo Court of Justice does not end the controversy nor eliminate the need for a case-by-case analysis of the measures that may be available to potentially affected companies. In this context, potentially affected companies may consider assessing, starting now, measures aimed at:
ruling out the inclusion of IBS and CBS in the ICMS and ISS tax bases;
reducing risks associated with the implementation of the new calculation methods;
preserving the right to recover amounts that may be improperly paid;
providing greater tax predictability during the transition to the new system.
Given that several tax authorities are already incorporating this interpretation into tax rulings, operational guidance, and electronic systems, the discussion is no longer a future concern and now calls for immediate analysis by companies’ tax, finance, and legal departments.
How we can help
The tax team at Araújo e Policastro Advogados continuously monitors administrative, legislative and judicial developments related to the Tax Reform transition and has already been advising companies in assessing the impacts of including IBS and CBS in the ICMS and ISS tax bases.
We are available to carry out individualized diagnostics, estimate the financial exposure of each transaction, assess the viability of preventive legal measures and structure strategies aimed at mitigating risks and preserving rights during the transition to the new tax system.gal measures and structure strategies aimed at mitigating risks and preserving rights during the transition to the new tax system.
| Alert: States and Municipalities are already incorporating, in tax rulings, operational guidance, and electronic systems, interpretations that assume IBS and CBS will be included in the ICMS and ISS tax bases starting in 2027. In light of this scenario, potentially affected companies should assess now the financial effects of the controversy and the advisability of adopting preventive measures aimed at mitigating risks and preserving the right to recover amounts that may have been improperly paid. |
Authors:
Fernanda Botinha Nascimento – fnascimento@araujopolicastro.com.br
Priscila Santos Rosa – prosa@araujopolicastro.com.br
Jéssica Aparecida de Loredo – jloredo@araujopolicastro.com.br
Maria Clara Murray – mmurray@araujopolicastro.com.br
